Mirlitons…mirla-what? Mirlitons. You may know them by their other names, chayote or vegetable pear, but these wrinkly, light green pear shaped members of the gourd family are yet another star of Creole cuisine.
Sweet Daddy D’s Mirlitons Stuffed with Shrimp and Creole Tomatoes is a no-angst recipe that shows what makes Creole and Cajun cuisines so special.
Introduced to Louisiana in the 18th century by the Spanish, these natives of South America, Central America and Mexico adapted well to the alluvial soils of the Louisiana delta. On their own, they are mild in flavor, but when mixed or stuffed with seafood and seasonings, they bloom into mind-blowing deliciousness. Creole cooks love to stuff things (it’s a great way to stretch out expensive meat and seafood, a la gumbos and jambalaya) and these stuffed mirlitons will show you why.
Here’s What You Need
Mirlitons, also known as chayote-are a peculiar looking light green, pear-shaped squash, called vegetable pears by some because of their shape, but these are indeed Mirlitons to the locals in New Orleans and South Louisiana. It’s not hard to find them in grocery stores all over the US. The entire mirliton will be used except the seed-the fruit will be scraped out and mixed with the other ingredients leaving the the hollowed out shells just dying to be stuffed. Creole Tomatoes are also a main ingredient in these Stuffed Mirlitons-grown in the alluvial soils of the river parishes in Louisiana, these vine ripened natives add a certain sweetness and texture to the dish. You can easily substitute any home grown or other fresh, ripe tomato, or even canned tomatoes. It will still be delicious. Next, fresh or frozen shrimp, the trinity-yellow onions, celery and bell peppers along with green onions and garlic are the vegetables. The Herb and Spice Blend is dried oregano, basil, thyme and bay leaves, plus some Creole Seasoning, kosher salt and black pepper and a little sugar to counter the acidity in the tomatoes. Butter starts it off and seasoned bread crumbs provide the binder, then a little Romano cheese on top finishes it up!
Here’s What You Do
First…you have a beer. There is some prep time involved to get the mirlitons soft and ready to scoop out the meat and leave a hollow shell ready for stuffing and then the tomatoes need to be peeled and seeded (unless you are using canned). So, pop a cold beer, read the recipe all the way through and begin your mise en place.
Mise en place. Place the whole mirlitons in about 10 cups of rapidly boiling water until they soften. This will take between 30 and 40 minutes-plenty of time to finely chop the onions, celery and bell peppers; place those together in a bowl. Chop the green onions and set them aside, then chop your garlic. Put the Herb and Spice Blend together in a ramekin along with the bay leaves; place the sugar in a separate ramekin. Measure out the breadcrumbs and the butter-4 tablespoons to saute the trinity plus another to place on top of the prepared mirlitons with some Romano cheese before they go in the oven. Peel and devein the shrimp. Rinse them well under cold water, then pat them dry with a paper towel and place them in a bowl. Sprinkle some creole seasoning on them and mix well before you set them aside.
Remove the meat from the mirlitons. Once the mirlitons are soft, remove them from the boiling water and let them cool so they will be easier to handle. Once cool, slice them long-ways along the widest part of the pear-shape. Using a spoon, scoop out the seed and discard, then carefully scoop out the meat, leaving about ¼” of the shell, which will be very soft. Place the meat in a colander that has been placed over a bowl so that the excess water will drain. Once drained, chop the mirliton meat and return to the strainer to continue to drain. Place the empty shells aside.
Peel and Seed the Tomatoes. With a sharp knife, cut a shallow cross on the stem end of the tomato and place in about 10 cups of rapidly boiling water. Boil for about 3 minutes once the water returns to a boil. Immediately remove the tomato from the boiling water and place it in an ice bath to halt the cooking. After 5 or 10 minutes, the tomatoes should be easy to peel-grab some of the loose skin between your thumb and the flat of a knife blade and pull. Once peeled, cut the tomato in 2 or 3 sections around the equator and squeeze out the seeds. A few remaining seeds won’t hurt anything. Chop the tomatoes.
Saute the Trinity. Melt the butter over high heat in a heavy bottomed dutch oven until its frothy. Add the yellow onions, bell peppers and celery and saute, stirring frequently until the onions are starting to clear, which will probably take about 8 minutes.
Add in the aromatics. Next throw in the garlic and the Herb and Spice Blend with some fresh ground pepper but not the salt or the sugar yet. Stir these into the veggie mix, then add the green onions. Keep stirring until everything is nice and aromatic-only about 3 or 4 minutes.
Add the tomatoes and mirliton meat. Mix in the tomatoes and whatever tomato juice has accumulated and saute for about 5 minutes, making sure the fire is high. Don’t let it burn! Next add the mirliton meat, without any extra liquid (reserve the mirliton juice for later if its needed). Continue to stir thoroughly, combining all the ingredients and cooking out some of the excess liquid. Smash the larger mirliton pieces with the back of your spoon. Stir in the sugar. All this should be about another 5 minutes.
Add the binder. Now it’s time to add the breadcrumbs to bind everything into a stuffing. Start with about half of the breadcrumbs-mix everything together very well. If it looks like it needs some more breadcrumbs, add about half of what’s left. I usually use about ¾ cup total breadcrumbs in the stuffing, but you should use whatever it takes to get the consistency you are looking for. If you end up adding too many breadcrumbs, just add in a little of the reserved mirliton juice and that should thin it out. Make sure to mix all of this together very well-taste and add kosher salt if needed, then set it aside and allow it to cool slightly.
Stuff the shells. Remove the bay leaves. Now, holding a mirliton shell in your left hand (if you’re right handled), use a spatula in your right hand to stuff some of the filling into the shell. Make sure to press down and get filling in all the voids. Place the stuffed mirlitons on the prepared baking sheet or baking pan. Once all the mirlitons have been stuffed, sprinkle some of the remaining breadcrumbs, a little Romano cheese and finally place a small tab of butter on top of each one.
Bake. After 30 minutes in a 375 degree oven, they should be starting to brown on top. Since ovens differ, check them after 20 minutes to get an idea how it’s going. Of course if they still haven’t browned after 30 minutes, give them a little more time.
That’s all there is to it. Simple as that.
Tips and Hints
- Mirlitons are mild in flavor, enhancing the flavors of the ingredients with which they are mixed. When these stuffed mirlitons are ready, the skin will be very soft and can be eaten along with the stuffing-very delicious.
- Mirlitons have a high water content. Once you have scooped out the meat, put it in a colander placed over a bowl. Let it drain while you are doing other things, then rough chop the mirliton and return it to the colander until you’re ready to add it to the cooking. It will seem like it’s still making water, but you’ll cook most of it out.
- Make sure you don’t rush the softening operation. If the mirlitons are not softened enough they will be very difficult to scoop out. Use a toothpick to test them. If they end up too soft-no worries, just be careful not to tear or poke a hole the skin. If you do and it’s not too bad, you can still mold them together. Worst case scenario-just make a casserole!
- If you don’t have Creole tomatoes, use any ripe tomato-homegrown are best, but the important thing is that they be ripe. If you don’t have any fresh tomatoes available, using diced canned tomatoes is a great substitute-best thing…they are already peeled and seeded, talk about no-angst!!
- Crawfish tails are also a great substitute for the shrimp. Everything remains the same, just swap your crustacean. Don’t like, can’t get or can’t eat shellfish? No worries..experiment with some spicy sausage-saute some fresh sausage before you add the butter and trinity, then just follow the rest of the steps.
- Remember that most commercial creole seasoning have a high salt content, so make sure that you taste the stuffing before you add any more salt.
These go great with all sorts of stuff-like Creole Green Beans, Roasted Carrots with Cane Syrup and of course a Sensation Salad. If you really loved these, you have to try Sweet Daddy D’s Eggplant and Shrimp Casserole.
I sure hope you try these Mirlitons Stuffed with Shrimp and Creole Tomatoes and when you do, please tell us about it in the Comments section below and make sure to leave a rating on the recipe. Post a picture on our Facebook page or on Instagram with a #firstyouhaveabeer. Pin it for later. Follow us on Facebook and Instagram and make sure to share this with your friends…they will love you for it. Sign up for our email updates below so you don’t miss anything!
Yeah You Right!